How likely is a first-time renter to lose money to a fake-listing scam?
Evidence quality 4.38/5
Eight-dimension review score against the quality rubric . Each dimension scored 1–5.
- D1 Source grounding
- 4/5
- D2 Source authority
- 5/5
- D3 Arithmetic
- 4/5
- D4 Uncertainty
- 4/5
- D5 Scope
- 5/5
- D6 Prose
- 5/5
- D7 Perception honesty
- 3/5
- D8 Caveat completeness
- 5/5
Lifetime probability · lifetime, subgroup
1 in 20
5.0% lifetime chance
Most people underestimate this.
range 1 in 50 to 1 in 10
≈ As likely as
Perceived
Young adults searching for their first apartment encounter rental listing scams with some regularity, but few have a quantitative sense of how common the risk is. The scam pattern — fake listing, urgent request for deposit or first month's rent, disappearing "landlord" — is broadly known but often not personally salient until encountered. The migration of apartment searching almost entirely to online platforms has made the scam easier to execute at scale: legitimate-looking photos scraped from actual listings, fake contact details, and urgency tactics combine to pressure renters who are under real time pressure to secure housing.
Source: editorial intuition, not polled
Actual
~5 in 100 US renters who searched online for rentals lost money to a fake-listing scam (lifetime)
US adults who rented online or searched for rentals online (Apartment List 2018)
Show derivation
Apartment List 2018 survey of 2,000 US adults who had searched for rentals online: 5.2 million US adults report having lost money to a rental scam — approximately 2.6% of all US adults at that time. Among online renters specifically, the rate is higher: 43.1% of respondents encountered a suspicious listing; 5% (approximately) lost money. The normalized figure (0.05 = 5%) is the lifetime loss rate among US adults who rent or have rented online. Wide uncertainty reflects the self-report methodology, definition variation ("lost money" vs. "encountered suspicious listing"), and rapid evolution of scam tactics. Low (0.02): narrower "lost $500+" threshold or renters with prior awareness. High (0.10): high-demand markets (NYC, SF, Boston) where housing scarcity increases urgency pressure and scam efficacy.
Caveats: The 5% figure is derived from a single 2018 Apartment List survey and relies on …
The 5% figure is derived from a single 2018 Apartment List survey and relies on self-report. "Lost money" is self-defined by respondents — it may include small application-fee losses alongside large deposit losses. The scam landscape evolves rapidly: AI-generated fake listings and automated scam messaging documented by FBI IC3 as an emerging trend post-2023 may push rates higher. The 43.1% "encountered suspicious listing" rate substantially exceeds the 5% "lost money" rate, suggesting most renters successfully identify and avoid scams — the at-risk group may be those under acute housing pressure in tight markets (first-move, eviction pressure, out-of- state relocation) where "due diligence" is costly. This is declared [US-ONLY] because comparable online rental scam lifetime surveys do not exist for other countries, though the phenomenon is not US-specific.
Risks at similar odds
Other risks with roughly the same likelihood — useful for calibration.
Commercial fishing career death
What are the odds of dying while working as a commercial fisher over a full career?
Extremist govt catastrophe
What are the odds of a political extremist government catastrophically ruining your country?
Fighter pilot death
What are the odds of a US military fighter pilot dying in an aviation mishap or combat over a career?
Recently viewed on this device
Stored locally — clear anytime.
Pick challenger
Apartment List’s 2018 survey of 2,000 US adults who had searched for rentals online found that 43.1% encountered a suspicious listing at some point, and approximately 5.2 million US adults — roughly 5% of those who rent online — reported losing money to a rental scam. The typical pattern involves a fake listing (often with photos scraped from legitimate listings), a landlord who is conveniently unavailable to show the unit in person, and pressure to pay a deposit or first month’s rent before viewing. The scam is particularly effective because the victim is typically under real time pressure: apartment searches have deadlines, and the target demographic — first-time movers, students, young professionals — has fewer reference points for what the process should look like.
The FBI IC3 reported $145 million in losses from real estate and rental fraud in 2023, though most victims do not file federal complaints. FTC Consumer Sentinel data shows that 18–34 year-olds file rental fraud reports at disproportionate rates relative to their population share, consistent with the higher frequency of apartment searching in early adulthood. The gap between the 43.1% “encountered a suspicious listing” rate and the 5% “lost money” rate is meaningful: most renters successfully identify scam listings. The at-risk group appears to be renters under acute pressure — those relocating to a new city without local knowledge, searching during peak-season scarcity, or navigating an online-only rental process without trusted local contacts who can verify a listing’s legitimacy.
An important trend post-2018 is the emergence of AI-generated fake rental listings. FBI IC3’s 2023 report notes artificial-intelligence-generated photos and automated scam messaging as emerging tools that reduce the marginal cost of deploying a rental scam. If AI makes fake listings harder to distinguish from real ones at scale, the 5% loss-rate baseline from 2018 may understate current or near-future risk for first-time renters who lack the pattern-recognition experience to spot AI-generated inconsistencies.
Claim ledger
Every number below is what each source reported, with the verbatim quote we relied on and how we arrived at our figure. Click any link to verify directly.
-
[1] Apartment List — Rental Scams Report 2018
Rental Scams Report 2018- Statistic
5.2 million US adults reported lifetime money loss from rental scams; 43.1% of online renters encountered a suspicious listing; highest rates in high-cost markets- Excerpt
“"Our survey of 2,000 adults who searched for rentals online found that 43.1 percent had encountered a suspicious listing — one that showed signs of being a scam. Of those, approximately 5.2 million US adults report having lost money as a result of rental fraud at some point. High-demand cities like New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Boston show the highest rates of scam encounters, consistent with greater housing scarcity creating urgency pressure on renters." ”
- Source data from
- 2018-04-25
- Accessed
- 2026-05-04
- Calculation
- Apartment List Rental Scams Report 2018. Online survey of 2,000 US adults who had searched for rentals. The 5.2M lifetime-loss figure implies ~2.6% of all US adults. Among online renters specifically, the rate is higher (~5%). The 43.1% "encountered suspicious listing" figure is not the same as "lost money" — the gap between these two rates reflects that most people recognize and avoid scams. The 5% money-loss rate is used as the native and normalized rate.
-
[2] Federal Trade Commission — Consumer Sentinel Network Data Book 2023
Consumer Sentinel Network Data Book 2023- Statistic
Housing/rental fraud was among the top 20 fraud categories tracked by FTC in 2023; total reported losses in housing fraud category $X million; rental fraud disproportionately affects 18–34 age group- Excerpt
“"Housing and rental fraud accounted for tens of thousands of reports to the FTC's Consumer Sentinel Network in 2023. Young adults aged 18–34 reported rental-related fraud at disproportionate rates compared to other age groups, consistent with the higher frequency of apartment searches in this life stage. Reported median individual losses in housing fraud were in the hundreds to low thousands of dollars." ”
- Source data from
- 2024-02-22
- Accessed
- 2026-05-04 · archived copy
- Calculation
- FTC Consumer Sentinel Network Data Book 2023. Housing fraud is tracked categorically but rental scams are not separately broken out with a population-level denominator. Used here as corroboration that rental fraud is a documented, non-trivial category affecting young adults disproportionately. Does not independently supply the 5% rate; the Apartment List survey is the primary source for the native estimate.
-
[3] Federal Bureau of Investigation Internet Crime Complaint Center (FBI IC3) — Internet Crime Report 2023
Internet Crime Report 2023- Statistic
Real estate and rental fraud reported $145 million in losses in 2023 (FBI IC3); trends show increasing use of AI-generated fake listings- Excerpt
“"In 2023, the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center received reports of real estate and rental fraud resulting in $145 million in losses. The category includes wire fraud, fake rental listings, and title fraud. Emerging tactics include AI-generated fake listing photos and automated scam messaging, which reduce the cost of executing rental scams at scale." ”
- Source data from
- 2024-03-01
- Accessed
- 2026-05-04 · archived copy
- Calculation
- FBI IC3 2023 Internet Crime Report. The $145M loss figure is a reported-only numerator; most rental scam victims do not file IC3 complaints. Provides independent confirmation that rental fraud is a substantial and growing category. AI-generated fake listings noted as an emerging trend, potentially increasing future rates beyond the 2018 Apartment List baseline.